What to ask it
- Explain the rubric. Ask how a dimension should be applied, or why an example counts as good or bad, so a new reviewer grades it the way an expert would.
- Draft a rationale. Have it write a short, clear rationale for a grade or a correction, which the reviewer edits and keeps.
- Suggest a correction. Ask for an improved version of the model’s answer, then drop it straight into the review as the corrected response. You can point it at one part, like the query, the prompt, a single step, or the final answer.
- Check the rubric itself. Ask it to flag gaps, ambiguities, or missing dimensions, so you can tighten the standard over time.
Next steps
Judges & Datasets
Calibrate a judge against this review data

